Skip to content

QA UX review: public pages and sign-in ​

Scope: /p/* (intake, call booking, quote, contract, set-password, payment return, invalid links) and /login.

Scores ​

AreaScoreNotes
Clarity of purpose7Each page has one heading and one action. The sign-in page does not say who it is for.
Visual hierarchy7Single column, one primary button per view. Good.
Consistency with the app6Login says "shoot&grow-crew", public pages say "Shoot & Grow".
Forms and feedback6Helper text explains disabled buttons. Invalid links showed raw validation text. No retry on load errors.
Mobile at 390px7Single column, sticky time footer on booking. No horizontal overflow seen.
Accessibility6Labels and aria-pressed on slots are in place. Honeypot was offscreen rather than hidden. Contract text is keyboard-scrollable.
Speed to complete6Intake, call, quote, contract and payment are five pages. The booking footer gave no sense of what would be booked.

What works ​

  • One unguessable link per step, with clear success states (booked, accepted, signed, paid).
  • Disabled submit buttons are explained in a helper line.
  • Quote states (accepted, declined, expired, closed) each say what to do next.
  • Set-password says the link works once and the password minimum up front.
  • The Development accounts block is gated by import.meta.env.DEV (login.tsx). In a production build the branch is statically false, so DevAccounts and its seat list are dropped. Verified in source; no bundle inspected.

Suggestions ​

  1. P1 Invalid links showed "Input validation failed" as the reason. Fixed in public-state.tsx (messageOf ignores validation text and shows the page's fallback).
  2. P1 Verify the dev block cannot ship. Verified above; no change needed.
  3. P2 Intake helper did not say that an email or phone is required until submit. Fixed in intake-form.tsx: the helper lists it with the other missing steps.
  4. P2 Booking footer did not show the chosen time before "Book this time". Fixed in call-booking.tsx: footer shows "Selected: <day> at <time>" or "Pick a time to continue."
  5. P2 Booking showed the raw zone id "Europe/London" to visitors. Fixed in call-booking.tsx: "London time". Quote and contract now use the shared APP_TIME_ZONE from lib/format-time.ts instead of local literals.
  6. P2 Intake honeypot was positioned offscreen at -9999px. Fixed in intake-form.tsx: now hidden.
  7. P2 Login two-factor toast used internal jargon ("foundation step 1"). Fixed in login.tsx.
  8. P2 Load errors ("This link is not valid") have no retry, so a network failure looks like a dead link. Not done: needs a distinction between network errors and NOT_FOUND across five views; deferred.
  9. P2 Contract says "Read the whole contract", but the agreement checkbox is not gated on scrolling. Not done: a legal and product decision, not a UI fix.
  10. P3 Login brand "shoot&grow-crew" differs from "Shoot & Grow" on public pages. Not done: naming decision for Main or the product owner.
  11. P3 Payment return page has no business name or next step beyond the email. Not done: the page has no data to show.

Changes made ​

  • apps/web/src/components/public/public-state.tsx: messageOf ignores server validation text.
  • apps/web/src/components/public/intake-form.tsx: contact-method helper line; honeypot hidden.
  • apps/web/src/components/public/call-booking.tsx: selected-time footer; "London time" label; zone label computed before first use.
  • apps/web/src/components/public/quote-view.tsx, contract-sign.tsx: use APP_TIME_ZONE.
  • apps/web/src/lib/format-time.ts: APP_TIME_ZONE exported.
  • apps/web/src/routes/login.tsx: two-factor toast copy.

Checks: bun x tsc --noEmit shows no errors in owned files (other errors in client-area and crew belong to other owners). oxfmt and oxlint were run once; see the final report.

Internal documentation. Not for clients.