Appearance
QA UX review: public pages and sign-in
Scope: /p/* (intake, call booking, quote, contract, set-password, payment return, invalid links) and /login.
Scores
| Area | Score | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Clarity of purpose | 7 | Each page has one heading and one action. The sign-in page does not say who it is for. |
| Visual hierarchy | 7 | Single column, one primary button per view. Good. |
| Consistency with the app | 6 | Login says "shoot&grow-crew", public pages say "Shoot & Grow". |
| Forms and feedback | 6 | Helper text explains disabled buttons. Invalid links showed raw validation text. No retry on load errors. |
| Mobile at 390px | 7 | Single column, sticky time footer on booking. No horizontal overflow seen. |
| Accessibility | 6 | Labels and aria-pressed on slots are in place. Honeypot was offscreen rather than hidden. Contract text is keyboard-scrollable. |
| Speed to complete | 6 | Intake, call, quote, contract and payment are five pages. The booking footer gave no sense of what would be booked. |
What works
- One unguessable link per step, with clear success states (booked, accepted, signed, paid).
- Disabled submit buttons are explained in a helper line.
- Quote states (accepted, declined, expired, closed) each say what to do next.
- Set-password says the link works once and the password minimum up front.
- The Development accounts block is gated by
import.meta.env.DEV(login.tsx). In a production build the branch is statically false, soDevAccountsand its seat list are dropped. Verified in source; no bundle inspected.
Suggestions
- P1 Invalid links showed "Input validation failed" as the reason. Fixed in
public-state.tsx(messageOfignores validation text and shows the page's fallback). - P1 Verify the dev block cannot ship. Verified above; no change needed.
- P2 Intake helper did not say that an email or phone is required until submit. Fixed in
intake-form.tsx: the helper lists it with the other missing steps. - P2 Booking footer did not show the chosen time before "Book this time". Fixed in
call-booking.tsx: footer shows "Selected:<day>at<time>" or "Pick a time to continue." - P2 Booking showed the raw zone id "Europe/London" to visitors. Fixed in
call-booking.tsx: "London time". Quote and contract now use the sharedAPP_TIME_ZONEfromlib/format-time.tsinstead of local literals. - P2 Intake honeypot was positioned offscreen at -9999px. Fixed in
intake-form.tsx: nowhidden. - P2 Login two-factor toast used internal jargon ("foundation step 1"). Fixed in
login.tsx. - P2 Load errors ("This link is not valid") have no retry, so a network failure looks like a dead link. Not done: needs a distinction between network errors and NOT_FOUND across five views; deferred.
- P2 Contract says "Read the whole contract", but the agreement checkbox is not gated on scrolling. Not done: a legal and product decision, not a UI fix.
- P3 Login brand "shoot&grow-crew" differs from "Shoot & Grow" on public pages. Not done: naming decision for Main or the product owner.
- P3 Payment return page has no business name or next step beyond the email. Not done: the page has no data to show.
Changes made
apps/web/src/components/public/public-state.tsx:messageOfignores server validation text.apps/web/src/components/public/intake-form.tsx: contact-method helper line; honeypothidden.apps/web/src/components/public/call-booking.tsx: selected-time footer; "London time" label; zone label computed before first use.apps/web/src/components/public/quote-view.tsx,contract-sign.tsx: useAPP_TIME_ZONE.apps/web/src/lib/format-time.ts:APP_TIME_ZONEexported.apps/web/src/routes/login.tsx: two-factor toast copy.
Checks: bun x tsc --noEmit shows no errors in owned files (other errors in client-area and crew belong to other owners). oxfmt and oxlint were run once; see the final report.