Appearance
QA UX review: videographer and editor (crew space)
Scores are for the screens before the fixes below. Desktop and mobile (390px) screenshots were reviewed for each page, plus the components behind them. The footage detail page has no screenshot, so it is rated from code.
Scores
| Dimension | Score | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Clarity of purpose | 7 | Each page says what it is for. Home and editor home are near-identical. |
| Visual hierarchy | 6 | Footage detail puts the player below the upload form. Sparse pages leave dashed empty boxes. |
| Consistency with app | 7 | Shares the crew shell. Dates used the browser zone, not London. |
| Forms and feedback | 5 | Several actions had no success feedback. Upload had no progress bar. |
| Mobile at 390px | 7 | Stacks cleanly. Availability day grid fits. |
| Accessibility | 6 | Generic "Cancel" and "Request" labels. Calendar had no date range. |
| Speed to main task | 7 | Upload, reply and sign-agreement are short paths. |
What works
- Home and footage lists are short and scannable, with clear "Waiting on you" signals.
- Availability uses a Monday-first grid with 44px touch targets and locks booked shoot days with a stated reason.
- Upload is idempotent: a failed upload keeps the file and id, so a retry does not create a second version.
- Payslip prints cleanly and offers a CSV download.
Suggestions
- P1, shared London time formatting. Crew dates used the browser zone. Done. Files:
apps/web/src/lib/format-time.ts,apps/web/src/components/crew/*.tsx. - P1, file size under 0.1 MB showed "0.0 MB". Done. File:
apps/web/src/components/crew/crew-video-detail.tsx(formatFileSize). - P1, upload had no progress bar and an ambiguous "Cancel". Done: progressbar role, "Cancel upload", button reads "Upload version", retry hint on error. File:
crew-video-detail.tsx. - P2, fulfil, reply and resolve gave no success feedback. Done: toasts on the detail page and on home. Files:
crew-video-detail.tsx,crew-home.tsx. - P2, calendar had no date range and no way back to today. Done: range line, "Back to today", nav stays visible while loading. File:
crew-calendar.tsx. - P2, calendar day headings had no weekday. Done: "Thursday 19 November" headings. File:
crew-calendar.tsx. - P2, availability summary counted away days outside the four-week window, and the button label doubled the pressed state. Done: count limited to the window,
aria-pressedalone conveys state. File:crew-availability.tsx. - P2, agreement start date showed raw ISO text and the disabled sign button gave no reason. Done: formatted date, reason line above the button, success toast on signing. File:
crew-agreement-page.tsx. - P2, pay run status showed raw enum values. Done: readable labels. File:
crew-earnings.tsx. - P2, the player sits below the upload form on footage detail, pushing the video down the page. Not done: the order is a product decision (upload first for crew, player first for review) and was left for the owner to choose.
Also noted, not done:
- P2, native file input and native checkbox instead of beUI controls. Not done: no beUI file control was evaluated for this pass; the checkbox was left native to keep the agreement change small.
- P3, editor home duplicates videographer home. Not done: a role split is a larger change than a P3 trivial fix.