Appearance
Client space UX review
Scope: client home, scripts, videos, billing, team, to-do, calendar, and the shared video player. Screenshots at 1365 and 390 wide in apps/docs/public/qa/client/.
Scores (1 to 10, before fixes)
| Criterion | Score | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Clarity of purpose | 6 | Each page has a purpose line, but home did not say what needed the client. |
| Visual hierarchy | 6 | Sections all shared one weight; the next action was not stated. |
| Consistency with the app | 5 | Two time zones (browser and London); "Pay" and "Logins" labels were unclear. |
| Forms and feedback states | 5 | Disabled buttons gave no reason; approve and delete were inconsistent (video confirmed, script did not). |
| Mobile at 390px | 7 | No horizontal scroll seen; action rows wrap. |
| Accessibility | 6 | Labels present; the video player had no name; delete buttons were unclear out of context. |
| Speed to complete main task | 6 | Approving a video takes 3 steps; the timestamp field asked for raw seconds. |
What works
- Every page has a header and a one-line summary of what it is for.
- Loading, empty, and error states exist on every view, with retry.
- Video approval already asks for confirmation.
- The beUI controls are used throughout, with no native selects or date inputs.
- Mobile layouts stack cleanly.
Suggestions
- P1,
client-dashboard.tsx: no line says what needs the client. Added a summary ("You have 1 script to approve and 2 videos to review"). Done. - P1,
billing-team-view.tsx: members saw an error page for billing. They now see a plain message that billing is for the account admin. Done (UI gate; see note below). - P1,
client-area-format.ts,client-calendar.tsx,client-dashboard.tsx,scripts-view.tsx,videos-view.tsx,todo-view.tsx,billing-team-view.tsx: timestamps used the browser zone in some places. All now use the shared London formatter inlib/format-time.ts. Done. - P1,
scripts-view.tsx: "Approve script" had no confirmation. Now it asks to confirm and says approval makes the script final. Done. - P2,
videos-view.tsx: the timestamp asked for raw seconds. It now accepts "1:23" or seconds, and "Use the time the video is at" fills it in. Done. - P2,
scripts-view.tsx,videos-view.tsx,billing-team-view.tsx: disabled buttons gave no reason. Hints now sit beside them. Done. - P2,
todo-view.tsx: Delete removed items with no confirmation. It now asks "Confirm delete" or "Cancel". Done. - P2,
billing-team-view.tsx: the "Pay" button did not say what it does. It now reads "Pay £1,000.00". Done. - P2,
billing-team-view.tsx,client-dashboard.tsx: "Logins" and "Request login" were jargon. Renamed to "Who can sign in" and "Invite someone". Done. - P3,
video-player.tsx: the player had no accessible name and no fallback text. Added both. Done.
Not done or partly done
- Server-side enforcement for billing.
packages/api/src/routers/v1/client-area.ts(thebillinghandler) already rejects non-admins, so the page is safe. The UI gate is a presentation change only. [INFERENCE]: the API error text is correct, so no API change is needed. - Sub-account requester shown as a raw user id. This is in the owner Access tab (
apps/web/src/components/owner/clients/access-rows.tsx) and the API (packages/api/src/client-area.ts, around line 551 setsrequestedBy: actor.userId). Outside my files; the client Team page only receives the email, so it cannot show a name. - Calendar windows still start at midnight in the browser zone. Labels now use London dates, but the window boundary is not London-aligned. Fixing that needs an API-side window; not done.
- Owner Money "Mark paid" confirmation, Insights blank space and file-size KB labels: owned by other spaces.